Relationship with God

The foundational question of your life

The most important question you will ever ask is “What is the foundational story by which I live my life”?

Most of us move through the ups and downs of life assuming that our thoughts are based solely on the reality we are experiencing. 

We are wrong. 

The Spanish poet and philosopher, Antonio Machado, put is finger on the challenge all of us face when he wrote,

“Under all that we think lives all we believe, like the ultimate veil of our spirits.” 

Machado, Antonio. “Juan De Mairena: Epigrams, Maxims, Memoranda and Memoirs of an Apocryphyl Professor.” page 75

Before you have them, your thoughts have been shaped by your beliefs.

Your beliefs are your fundamental presumptions. They can largely be grouped into four major headings:

  • Presumptions about Yourself
  • Presumptions about Other People
  • Presumptions about the World
  • Presumptions about God

Some of your presumptions were inherited from your parents and friends. Some have come as a result of your attempts to make sense of your past experiences. Some have come from the culture you grew up in. And some of your presumptions have come through the media you consume.

As you sit in a classroom, walk down a street or engage in a conversation, your presumptions work together like a map to help you make sense of the moment you are in. As social researcher Hugh Mackay wrote:

We perceive selectively; we observe what’s there from our own perspective. We unconsciously filter out those messages in our environment which are not relevant to our existing needs, interests or points of view.

 Hugh Mackay, Why don’t people listen?: (1994)

While some of your presumptions are definitely true, some are also definitely false… and you don’t know the difference. 

The pain of Cognitive Dissonance

I still remember seeing my beautiful two-year-old daughter’s frustration levels grow as she repeatedly tried to get into the driver’s seat of the Care Bear’s Cloud Car.

The car was about 30 centimeters long and the drivers seat was maybe 3 centimeters wide. Maddi was small but she wasn’t that small. She persisted for about ten minutes until the sense of bewilderment she was feeling gave way to frustration and then sadness. 

What Maddi was experiencing was something that everyone who has a false presumption has to face: the crisis of Cognitive Dissonance.

Cognitive Dissonance can be bewildering, frustrating and even upsetting, but it is an experience we all need to have on a regular basis if we are to grow as human beings. 

The pain of Cognitive Dissonance causes you to make changes to your map. Leon Festinger named this particular form of pain in 1954. He said it was:

“the feeling of psychological discomfort produced by the combined presence of two thoughts that do not follow from one another. Festinger proposed that the greater the discomfort, the greater the desire to reduce the dissonance of the two cognitive elements”

Cognitive Dissonance: Progress on a Pivotal Theory in Social Psychology.

The pain that builds your story

Cognitive Dissonance plays an important role in helping you navigate the world by making sure your many and varied presumptions about yourself, others, the world, and God, weave together into one map or story of the world.

Craig Bartholomew and Michael Goheen point out:

“To be human means to embrace some such basic story through which we understand our world and chart our course through it.  This does not mean that individuals are necessarily conscious of the story they are living out of or of the moulding effect that such a story has had on their thoughts and actions.”

The Drama of Scripture: Finding Our Place in the Biblical Story

Your story, and the presumptions it is based on, was the map that you used to make every decision you made today.

For all intents and purposes, you are a product of your story. As Dr. Dan McAdams from Northwestern University writes, your identity is:

“the internalized and evolving story that results from a person’s selective appropriation of past, present and future.”

The Authenticity Paradox in the Harvard Business Review (January 2015)

Getting to know your story

Most people are only barely aware that they have presumptions in the first place and are profoundly unaware of the foundational story by which they live their lives. 

Psychologist Carl Jung started to explore the basic stories people believed and realised that in order to grow as a person he needed to find a way to name his foundational story. He wrote

“I took it upon myself to get to know “my” myth, and I regarded this as the task of tasks…”

C.G. Jung, Symbols of Trasformation

Growing as a human-being means doing the hard work of facing the presumptions behind your foundational story, and being willing to change them when it becomes clear they are not accurate maps of reality.

By the end of her cloud car experience, cognitive dissonance had caused Maddi to change one of her presumptions and as a result, she had a more accurate map.

Three strategies to avoid the pain

The pain of cognitive dissonance, though, does not always produce growth. There are three strategies we all use at different times to minimise the pain of conflicting information and as a result, avoid growth:

  1. You can choose to surround yourself with information that reinforces rather than challenges your current presumptions. (For example a Christian who only reads books that reenforce their fear of science, or the atheist who won’t read reasoned arguments for faith)
  2. You can tell yourself a story about the information that reduces the pain of the conflicting stories. (For instance, the smoker who tells themselves they can’t quit so why worry about it, or the climate change skeptic who says there is nothing we can do anyway).
  3. You can re-interpret the information so that it no longer challenges your point of view (For example someone who believes climate change is a hoax to usher in one-world government or that the holocaust never happened).

Over the last 20 years, technology has allowed us more and more control over the information we absorb, and therefore the ability to employ the three cognitive dissonance avoidance strategies. 

Like never before in history, it is possible to live in your own echo chamber. Now you are the news editor, television programmers, professor and minister that determines what news stories, videos, ‘expert’ opinion and religious input you receive.

Our grandparents grew up in a world that was limited by geography and communication.

We are growing up in a world limited only by our presumptions and foundational stories and as a result, we are becoming more and more polarised and we are trusting our leaders less and less.

Commentators across the world are trying to understand the source of the polarisation (see this article, or this one, or this one).

In Psalm 11, David captures the dilemma of our moment:

“When the foundations are being destroyed, what can the righteous do?”

Psalm 11:3

According to the biblical scholar, Gerald H. Wilson, David is saying something like:

“In a world and society run amok, where the dignity of life is casually ignored and raw power rules in the place of justice, righteousness, and equity, what can a righteous person hope to do?”

 NIV Application Commentary Psalms: Psalm 11

Most of us can identify with David’s question. 

Freedom is our problem

The Cambridge Dictionary says that freedom is:

The condition or right of being able or allowed to do, say, think etc. whatever you want to do, without being controlled or limited.

This definition of freedom would capture the essence of what our society says is the ultimate goal of the individual. We aspire to be people who can do what we want to do.

The problem with this is the “you” that is doing the wanting. As we have already said, “you” are shaped by your presumptions and the foundational story you believe. This is the kind of life that the Apostle Paul dubbed “indulging the sarx”.

Most English translations render the Greek word sarx as “flesh”, but the use of “flesh” unfortunately conjures sexual undertones rather than the breadth of what Paul is actually saying when he says:

You, my brothers and sisters, were called to be free. But do not use your freedom to indulge the flesh; rather, serve one another humbly in love.

 Galatians 5:13 

For Paul, the sarx is what the Cambridge Dictionary definition of freedom calls ‘you’. It is the human nature, with all of its presumptions.

Paul knows that there is a kind of freedom that is actually dangerous, in fact, earlier (5:1) he writes that freedom itself can lead to slavery. This is something that every addict in the world also knows.

Paul says that freedom is not doing what you want to do, but actually the intentional choice to subject yourself to the control and limit of loving other people. 

This echoes what Jesus described as the only way to find life:

“Whoever wants to be my disciple must deny themselves and take up their cross and follow me. For whoever wants to save their life will lose it, but whoever loses their life for me will find it.”

Matthew 16:24-25

It seems as though Christians have often overlooked the truly revolutionary nature of our faith because we have unquestioningly adopted the world’s definition of freedom and sought to fit our faith into that self-focussed mould. 

The revolutionary nature of our faith

The central claim of Christianity is that it is a foundational story that represents the objective reality of the world. At the end of the world’s most famous, and important, sermon,  Jesus makes a startling claim:

“Therefore everyone who hears these words of mine and puts them into practice is like a wise man who built his house on the rock. The rain came down, the streams rose, and the winds blew and beat against that house; yet it did not fall, because it had its foundation on the rock. But everyone who hears these words of mine and does not put them into practice is like a foolish man who built his house on sand. The rain came down, the streams rose, and the winds blew and beat against that house, and it fell with a great crash.”

 Matthew 7:24-27

Jesus is claiming that his words describe a bedrock reality. He is saying that your foundational story will be effective as a map to navigate reality only to the extent that it mirrors His foundational story. 

The pale grey imitation of Christianity

The Christian church has watered down the power of Jesus’s words and has told a story that has been largely about fitting into people’s existing foundational and self-interested stories.

What we called “the Gospel” was primarily about being saved from feelings of guilt and fears about what happens when we die.

Christianity was never meant to be a set of ideas that sit on top of our foundational stories, it was always meant to be a story that confronted the presumptions and foundational story by which we live our lives. 

To be a follower of Jesus is to be in a continual process of cognitive dissonance as his story challenges the presumptions behind your story, and you gradually become freer and healthier as your life more and more reflects his. 

C.S. Lewis wrote about the temptation to trust our foundational story and where we find our true story:

The more I resist Him and try to live on my own, the more I become dominated by my own heredity and upbringing and surroundings and natural desires. In fact what I so proudly call “Myself” becomes merely the meeting place for trains of events which I never started and which I cannot stop…

I am not, in my natural state, nearly so much of a person as I like to believe: most of what I call “me” can be very easily explained. It is when I turn to Christ, when I give myself up to His Personality, that I first begin to have a real personality of my own.

C.S. Lewis Beyond Personality: The Christian idea of God

The healthy Christian journey is one where you are continually experiencing the pain of cognitive dissonance as you compare your foundational story to the truth of who Jesus is.

As you do this, people will see that you are becoming freer and freer, as you start to have a real personality of your own.


Discover more from Faith Reflections

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

2 Comments

  • Kerry and Val Morris

    Thank you Matt. That makes sense of our 2 year old in the States constantly trying to share her food and play dough with us over Skype! We have introduced her to singing over Skype now while she “accompanies ” us on the keyboard, we sing loudly! Every blessing to you and yours. Val and Kerry Morris

I'd love to hear what you think...

Discover more from Faith Reflections

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading